Windy Brow Farms
Scratch bakery, hyper-seasonal ice cream, and wood-fired pizza nights on a ridge-top orchard.
Category
Food & Drink
Looking for a place to eat or drink in Sussex County? This is where we round up local favorites, from Yellow Cottage Bakery’s fresh baked goods to sit-down spots like Early American Tavern and Black Forest Inn. Whether you want a casual bite at Bone Yard or a pint from Twin Soles Brewing, you’ll find it in the list below.
Hyde-Away Restaurant & Tap Room
Elevated dining and a serious tap list in a historic Stillwater building.
Cafe Pierrot – Sparta Cafe
A French bakery and bistro that's been a Sussex County staple for 30 years.
Cloveberry
An organic, local-first cafe tucked into an old house near Lake Mohawk.
Greene’s Beans Cafe
Small-batch roasted coffee and tea from a genuine local roaster.
Krogh’s Restaurant & Brew Pub
A Lake Mohawk landmark since 1927, brewing its own beer across the street from the water.
Millside Cafe
A go-to breakfast and lunch stop right next to the antiques mill.
Mohawk House
A farm-to-table fine dining estate with a serious beer and wine list.
The Circle
Two Jean-Georges alums cooking farm-to-table fine dining in a 1720 farmhouse.
Twin Soles Brewing
Two paths. One dream. Exceptional craft beer in the heart of Sussex County.
Lake House Cafe (Andover)
Breakfast and brunch inside a grist mill with Revolutionary War roots.
Part of Lake House Cafe (Sparta)
Andover Diner
A classic Jersey diner in the heart of Andover Borough.
Black Forest Inn
Classic German-Continental dining that's held its standard for decades.
Holland American Bakery
Dutch-inspired baked goods from a family bakery running since the 1950s.
The Walpack Inn
Dinner in the middle of nowhere, with deer grazing outside the windows.
Vernon Brew Works / Alias Brew Works
Vernon's craft brewery, parked squarely between Mountain Creek, Crystal Springs, and Minerals.
Seasonal
Ventimiglia Vineyard
A family-run winery in Wantage where small-batch wines meet picnic tables and quiet hiking trails
Alice’s
Lakeside American comfort food with floor-to-ceiling water views.
Bone Yard
Authentic Mexican and killer mocktails in a Day-of-the-Dead art-filled room on White Deer Plaza.
Sweet and Swirled
Sweet and Swirled Brings Something Special to Newton's Spring Street
Bell’s Mansion
Everything from burgers to duck in a restored 1800s mansion, seven days a week.
Dominick’s Pizzeria
Newton's oldest pizzeria, family-run for more than 40 years.
Industry Kitchen + Bar
A striking, vintage-factory-styled restaurant from the team behind Mohawk House.
Old Stone
Family-run breakfast in Sussex NJ with taylor ham rolls, daily baking, and house-roasted coffee
