Featured
The Farmer’s Daughter
Farm-to-table dining and a rustic market of local finds in the heart of Newton, NJ
Category
Restaurants & Dining
Looking for a place to eat in Sussex County? This page rounds up 27 restaurants and dining spots across the area, from the historic Bell’s Mansion to casual favorites like Bone Yard and Sweet and Swirled. Browse the list below to find something that fits whatever you’re in the mood for.
Curd & Cleaver
A gourmet deli and cheese shop in downtown Newton, NJ
Part of The Farmer’s Daughter
St. Moritz Grill & Bar
Wood-fired grilling on White Deer Plaza, plus the chicken schnitzel Sparta argues about
Andre’s Lakeside Dining
Chef André deWaal's BYOB fine dining room on the shore of Seneca Lake in Sparta
Arbor Restaurant
Arbor Restaurant serves a prix fixe menu cooked by culinary students in downtown Newton
Bearded Baby Que
Hardwood-smoked Texas BBQ in Sussex NJ, from a family that started with a garage full of string lights
Cow Patty’s
Flame-grilled Certified Angus burgers in Wantage NJ, built on beef raised right up the road
Perona Farms
Five generations of weddings, banquets and world famous smoked salmon in Andover NJ
Sparta Annex Bakery & Kitchen
French pastries by morning, Southern fried chicken by night, all on Sparta Ave
The Windlass
Year-round waterfront dining on Lake Hopatcong, with dock space for boaters and a boat-shaped bar
Early American Tavern | Sussex NJ
A new Sussex, NJ restaurant inside an 1843 landmark building
Holy Chick! Mother Cruster!
Detroit-style pizza and Nashville hot chicken under one roof on Route 23 in Franklin
Restaurant Latour
Crystal Springs Resort's tasting menu room, where the sunset over the Kittatinnys is course one
Part of Crystal Springs Resort
Lafayette House
A multi-tiered tavern and dining room that's anchored Lafayette for three decades.
Part of The Shoppes at Lafayette: A Revived Shopping Village in Sussex County, NJ
O’Reilly’s Pub & Grill
A late-night Irish pub in the heart of downtown Newton.
Windy Brow Farms
Scratch bakery, hyper-seasonal ice cream, and wood-fired pizza nights on a ridge-top orchard.
Hyde-Away Restaurant & Tap Room
Elevated dining and a serious tap list in a historic Stillwater building.
Cafe Pierrot – Sparta Cafe
A French bakery and bistro that's been a Sussex County staple for 30 years.
Cloveberry
An organic, local-first cafe tucked into an old house near Lake Mohawk.
Greene’s Beans Cafe
Small-batch roasted coffee and tea from a genuine local roaster.
Krogh’s Restaurant & Brew Pub
A Lake Mohawk landmark since 1927, brewing its own beer across the street from the water.
Mohawk House
A farm-to-table fine dining estate with a serious beer and wine list.
The Circle
Two Jean-Georges alums cooking farm-to-table fine dining in a 1720 farmhouse.
Andover Diner
A classic Jersey diner in the heart of Andover Borough.
